The ODISHA HINDU RELIGIOUS ENDOWMENTS ACT, 1951
Odisha · state statute
Open in Lexace · Ask the AI about this act*THE ODISHA HINDU RELIGIOUS ENDOWMENTS ACT, 1951 An Act to provide for the better administration and governance of Hindu Religious Institutions and Endowments in the State of Odisha Whereas it is expedient to amend and consolidate the law relating the administration and governance of Hindu Religious Institutions and Endowments in the State of Odisha. It is hereby enacted as follows : CHAPTER – I PRELIMINARY 1. Short title, extent, application and commencement :– (1) This Act may be called the Odisha Hindu Religious Endowments Act, 1951. (2) It extends to the whole of the State of Odisha and applies to all Hindu Public Religious Institutions and Endowments. Explanation I – In this Sub-Section Hindu Public Religious Institutions and Endowments do not include Jain or Buddhist Public Religious Institutions and Endowments but include Sikh Public Religious Institutions and Endowments. Explanation II – 1[xxx] (3) It shall come into force on such date2 as the State Government may, by notification, direct. 2. Power to extend Act to Jain or Buddhist Institutions and Endowments :– The State Government may, by notification, extend to any Jain or Buddhist Public Religious Institution and Endowment or to any Public Endowments or a Charitable and Religious Institution all or any of the provisions of this Act and of any rules made thereunder and may declare such extension to be subject to such restrictions and modifications as they think fit : * Published vide Odisha Act 11 of 1952. For Statement of Objects and Reasons, see Odisha Gazette Ext./10.03.1951, p. 49; and for Report of Select Committee, see ibid, 17.9.1951, pp. 1-10, and for proceedings in the Assembly, see Proceedings of the Odisha Legislative Assembly, Vol. XIV, No. 23, pp. 8-11. 1. Omitted vide O.H.R.E. (Amendment) Act, 1954 (O.A. No. 18 of 1954). 2. The Act came into force with ef fect from the 1st January, 1955, vide Notification No. 7631-End./22.12.1055 - published vide Odisha Gazette, Part-III/31.12.1955. The Odisha Gazette EXTRAORDINARY PUBLISHED BY AUTHORITY Provided that before issuing such notification, the State Government shall, publish in the Gazette a notice of their intention to do so, fix a period not exceeding three months from the date of publication of the notice for the persons interested in the institution and endowment concerned to show-cause against the issue of such notification and consider their objections, if any. SYNOPSIS 1. Substituted vide Odisha Gazette Ext./7.10.1978-O.A. No. 29 of 1978. 2. Omitted vide O.H.R.E. (Amendment) Act, 1954 A. No. 18 of 1954. 3. Inserted vide Odisha Gazette Ext./7.10.1978-O.A. No. 29 of 1978. 4. Substituted vide O.A. No. 18 of 1954. Modes to Recognize Hereditary Trustee : A claim to the hereditary trustee can be recognized if the three modes as provided in the said section are proved, 61 (1986) Sn. 49 (Rama Chandra Misra Vs. Hadibandhu Panda and others) 3. Definitions :– In this Act unless there is anything repugnant in the subject or context– (i) “Assist ant Commissioner” means an Assistant Commissioner appointed under Section 5; (ii) “Commissioner” means the Commissioner appointed under 1[Section-4]; (iii) “Collector” in any provision under this Act includes (a) any Deputy Collector who is specially empowered by the State Government to discharge any of the functions of a Collector under that provision; and (b) any Deputy Collector to whom the Collector may, by general or special order, transfer any of his functions under that provision; 2[xxx] 3[(iv) “Deputy Commissioner” means the Deputy Commissioner appointed under Section 5 :] 4[(v) “Endowment Fund” means the Odisha Hindu Religious Endowments Administration Fund constituted under Section 63;] (vi) “Heredit ary Trustee” means the Trustee of a Religious institution succession to whose Office devolves by hereditary right since the time of the founder or is regulated by custom or is specifically provided for by the founder, so long as such scheme of succession is in force; 2[xxx] (vii) “Math” means an institution for the promotion of the Hindu religion presided over by a person whose duty is to engage himself in spiritual service or who exercises or claims to exercise spiritual headship over a body of disciples and succession to whose Office devolves in accordance with the directions of the founder of the institution or is regulated by custom and includes places of Religious worship other than a temple and also places of instruction or places for the maintenance of Vidyarthis or places for rendering charitable or Religious services in general which are or may be appurtenant to such institution; (viii) “non-Hereditary Trustee” means a Trustee who is not a hereditary Trustee; (ix) 1[xxx] (x) “person having interest” means - (a) in the case of a math a disciple of the math or a person 2[at the Religious persuasion] to which the math belongs; (b) in the case of temple, a person who visits or who is entitled to visit the temple for darsan of the deity or attend at the performance of worship or service in the temple or who is in the habit of attending such performance or of p artaking in the benefit of the distribution of gif ts thereat and in the case of a specific endowment, a person who visits or who is entitled to attend at or is in the habit of attending the performance of the service or charity, or who is entitled to partake or is in the habit of p artaking in the benefit of the charity; (xi) “prescribed” means prescribed by rules made by the S tate Government under this Act; (xii) “Religious Endowment” or “Endowment” means all property belonging to or given or endowed for the support of maths or temples or given or endowed for the performance of any service or charity connected therewith or of any other Religious charity and includes the institution concerned and the premises thereof and also all properties used for the purposes or benefit of the institution and includes all properties acquired from the income of the endowed property; Provided that gif ts of immovable properties made as personal gif ts to hereditary Trustee of a math or temple or the archaka, sevaka, service-holder or other employee of a Religious institution shall not be so included, if the donee has been possessing and enjoying the same as a separate and distinct identity all long; Explanation I :– Any jagir or inam granted to an archaka, sevaka, service- holder or other employee of a Religious institution for the performance of any service or charity in or connected with a Religious institution shall not be deemed to be a personal gift to the said archaka, service-holder or employee but shall be deemed to be a Religious endowment. 1. Omitted vide O.H.R.E. (Amendment) Act, 1954-O.A. No. 18 of 1954. 2. Substituted vide Odisha Gazette Ext. 7.10.1978-O.A. No. 29 of 1978, w.e.f. 7.7.1978. Explanation II :– Any property which belonged to or was given or endowed for the support of a Religious institution, or which was given or endowed for the performance of any service or charity of a public nature connected therewith or of any other Religious charity shall be deemed to be a “Religious endowment” or “endowment” within the meaning of this definition, notwithstanding that, before or after the commencement of this Act, the Religious institution has ceased to exist or ceased to be used as a place of Religious worship or inspection, or the service or charity has ceased to be performed; 1[Provided that this Explanation shall not be deemed to apply in respect of any property which is vested in any person before the commencement of this Act by the operation of the law of limitation;] Explanation III :– Where an endowment has been made or property given for the support of an institution which is partly of Religious and partly of a secular Character or where an endowment made or property given is appropriated partly Religious and partly to secular uses, such endowment or property or the income therefrom shall be deemed to be a Religious endowment and its administration shall be governed by the provisions of this Act. Explanation IV :– 2[xxx] (xiii) “Religious Institution” means a math, a temple and endowment attached thereto or a specific endowment and includes an institution under direct management of the State Government; (xiv) “S pecific Endowment” means any property or money endowed. (a) for the performance of any specific service or charity in a math or temple, or (b) for the performance of any other Religious charity, but does not include any jagir or inam of the nature described in Explanation I to Clause (xii); (xv) “T emple” means a place by whatever designation known, used as a place of public Religious worship and dedicated to, or for the benefit of, or used as of right by , the Hindu community, or 3[any class or section thereof,] as a place of public Religious worship and also includes any cultural institution or mandap or library connected with such a place of public Religious worship; (xvi) “T rustee” means a person by whatever designation known, in whom the administration of a Religious institution and endowment are vested and includes any person or body who or which is liable as if such person or body were a Trustee; (xvii) “year” means the financial year. 1. Added vide O.H.R.E. (Amendment) Act, 1954-O.A. No. 18 of 1954. 2. Omitted vide O.H.R.E. (Amendment) Act, 1954-O.A. No. 18 of 1954. 3. Substituted ibid. SYNOPSIS 1. There cannot be a straight jacket formula to be a hereditary trustee. .................................................... 35 2. Installation of Idols is not enough to establish a Temple ....................... 35 3. Succession to the Hereditary Trustee ....................................... 35 4. Meaning of the word “T rustee” . 35 5. Constituting Hereditary Trustee.. 35 6. Person having Interest ................ 36 7. Hereditary Trustee ...................... 36 8. De-jure and De-facto Trustee ...... 36 9. Meaning of the word “Temple” . 36 10. R.O.R. is not enough to establish claim of Trusteeship .................... 36 11. Onus to establish claim over the Property ...................................... 37 12. Powers to determine the status of trustees ........................................ 37 13. Whether temples of the Society registered under Society Registra- tion Act can be treated as a Public Temples ...................................... 37 1. There cannot be a straight jacket formula to be a her editar y trustee :– Whether a person is a hereditary trustee of a public religious endowment which includes matha and temple will depend upon the facts of each case and there cannot be a straight jacket formula applicable to all cases, 2012 (II) OLR 639 (Danardan Mohapatra and Others Vs. Pitamber Jena and Others) 2. Installation of Idols is not enough to establish a Temple :– Distinction between mathas and temples and its definition – Explained – Merely if same idols are installed in a matha and members of the public are of fering worship to such idols would not make the same a temple. 201 1 (II) CLR (SC) 958 (Parasamaya Kolerinatha Madam Tirunelveli Vs. P . Natesa Achari and others) 3. Succession to the Her editary Trustee :– Succession to the of fice of hereditary trustee – the right being hereditary since the period of the founder duly regulated by custom and is specifically provided by the founder if the same remains in force is to be followed with regard to the succession to the office of hereditary trustee, 108 (2009) CLT 349, 2009 (II) CLR 409, 2009 (Supp. II) OLR 922 (Benudhar Hota and others Vs. Jagannath Nayak and others) 4. Meaning of the word “T rustee”:– Meaning of the word ‘Trustee’ – Explained – Usually a trustee is a person in whom the administration of religious institutions and endowment is vested, which may be any person or a body, 108 (2009) CLT 349, 2009 (II) CLR 409, 2009 (Supp. II) OLR 922 (Benudhar Hota and others Vs. Jagannath Nayak and others), 2012 (II) OLR 639 (Danardan Mohapatra and others Vs. Pitamber Jena and others) 5. Constituting Her editar y Trustee :– Constitution of the hereditary trustee as per Section 3 (vi). There are mainly three distinct ways by which the hereditary trustee can be constituted and approved when succession to the of fice devolves by hereditary right since the time of the founder. Secondly, succession to the hereditary trustee is regulated by customs and usages and thirdly, as per the scheme specifically laid down by or provided by the founder so long the said scheme is in force. 2007 (II) CLR 796, 2007 (Supp. II) OLR 1109 (Smt. Rukmini Mishra Vs. Sri Sri Radhakrushna Mahaprabhu and others) 6. Person having Inter est :– Meaning of the term “person having interest” – Explained – means a disciple of the matha or a person professing the hindu religious or sikh faith to which the matha belongs, 61 (1986) CL T 189 (Mahanta Sri Raghunath Das and another Vs. Commissioner of Hindu Religious Endowment, Orissa, Bhubaneswar) 7. Her editar y Trustee :– The definition of the term hereditary trustee provides for three distinct ways by which a claim of hereditary trusteeships can be proved namely: (i) Firstly, when succession to such office devolves by hereditary right since the time of the founder. (ii) Secondly, when succession to the office is regulated by custom, and (iii) Thirdly, when it is specifically provided for by the founder according to the scheme of succession so long as such scheme is in force. The mere fact that a person was a trustee for a very long period will not be sufficient for a declaration that he is a hereditary trustee, 62 (1986) CLT 576 (Gopinath Das Adhikari and Others Vs. Sri Chaitanya Mahaprabhu and Others) Burden lies on the person who claimed right of hereditary trusteeship to establish that succession to the of fice devolved upon by hereditary right since the time of the founder of the institution, since the evidence being unsatisfactory it is dif ficult to establish the case of hereditary trusteeship. 67 (1989) CLT 829 (Maheswar Das and others Vs. Sri Nilakantheswar Mahadeb and others. Ingredience of the word hereditary trustee – explained – the person ascertaining such rights must establish and prove to show that he comes within the three categories, 73 (1992) CL T 303 (Hindu Public represented through Jadunath Das and others Vs. Sankarsan Das and others) 8. De-jur e and De-facto Trustee :– Distinction between the term De-jure trustee and De-facto trustee – Explained – Further the meaning of the term trustee explained. A person having a legal right to hold the office of the trustee is a de-jure trustee whereas a de-facto trustee is one who is in possession of the endowment and exercises all the functions of the trustee though a legal title is lacking. The Odisha Hindu Religious Endowment Act defines the word “trustee” to mean a person by whatever designation known, in whom the administration of a religious institution and endowment are vested and includes any person or body who or which is liable as if such person or body were a trustee, thus the term trustee is a very wide one and would include a de-facto trustee who by his own action and conduct make himself liable as a trustee, 63 (1987) CLT 115 (Radhakrushna Dutta and others Vs. State of Orissa and Others) 9. Meaning of the word “T emple”:– Meaning of the word temple means a temple in common parlance. It is not enough that a deity installed in a building or the place would be the abode of the deity. The definition requires that it shall be a place of worship dedicated to the public or dedicated for the public or used as of right by the public, 63 (1987) CLT 223 (Kunja Bihari Parida Vs. Sri Narayani Thakurani and Others) 10. R.O.R. is not enough to establish claim of Trusteeship :– Principles of the backward and forward presumption – explained – merely because record of rights indicating a person as a ruler showing as a sebayat cannot be said that the institutions were founded by him or by any office ancestors, 72 (1991) CLT 277 (Raghunath Das after him Kamini Dei @ Krishna Kamini Dei and others Vs. Sri Grama Devati Ambica Thakurani and others) Categories of hereditary trust – defined – 72 (1991) CL T 530 (Sri Rama Chandra Rana and others Vs. Hindu Public and Shri Kaleswar Mahadev at Kalarapadar and others) Meaning of the term hereditary trustee means trustee of religious institution succession to whose of fice devolves to hereditary right since the time of the founder or is regulated by custom or is specifically provided for by the founder , so long as such scheme of succession is in force. 71 (1991) CLT 32 (Alekha Chandra Swain and others Vs. Nrusinghanath Thakur and others). If by the passage of time it is not possible to trace back to the time of founder , the principles of Lost grant and backward presumptions is available for the Courts to be drawn from the evidence available from the records backward presumption of lost grant theory cannot be drawn as there is paucity of materials to draw such presumption, 71 (1991) CLT 339 (Shyama Charan Pradhan and Others Vs. Naikhani Thakurani and others) 11. Onus to establish claim over the Property :– Onus lies on the plaintiff to prove that the mahanta who sold the properties to him was the absolute owner of the property – Inference cannot be drawn from the act or omission of the authorities under the Endowment Act and Collector to confer title of the property on the mahanta as a owner of the properties, 2004 (I) CLR 71, (Madhu Sudan Panda and after him Mukta Devi and others Vs. The Commissioner of Endowment, Orissa and others) Appointment of non-hereditary trustee by the Additional Assistant Commissioner of Endowment. The tenure of the order having been expired operating for more than 1½ yrs. The Hon’ble Court was not inclined to interfere the order, 98 (2004) CLT 221, 2004 (II) OLR 174, 2004 (II) CLR 657 (Dibyakanta Dash Vs. The Commissioner of Endowment, Orissa, Bhubaneswar and others) please also see 2004 (4) CCC 56, 98 (2004) CL T 357, 2004 (II) OLR 229, 2004 (II) CLR 418, (Shri Mahadev Bisi and others Vs. Niranjan Bisi) 12. Powers to determine the status of trustees :– The authorities under the Act are empowered to determine as to whether the institution is without hereditary trustee or not after appreciating the evidence available on record. AIR 1995 Orissa 197, 79 (1995) CLT 135 (Sri Kanteisuni Thakurani Vs. Sri Babudhar Rout) 13. Whether temples of the Society r egister ed under Society Registration Act can be tr eated as a Public Temples :– Determination of the nature and character of the temples of the Society whether are public temples or temples confined only for the members of the society. It cannot be conceived that any charitable dispensary run by the members of the society can be said only confined to the members of the society and the Dur ga Pujas and other pujas organized in the temples by the said society are only for the members, 88 (1999) CLT 60 (SC) (Hindu Public and others Vs. Rajadhanee Puja Samithee and others) CHAPTER - II POWERS AND DUTIES OF COMMISSIONER AND OTHERS 1[4. Appointment of Commissioner :– The State Government may, by notification, appoint a person who professes the Hindu religion 2[and who is a member of the Odisha Superior Judicial Service, Senior Branch] to be the Commissioner of Endowments and he shall cease to hold Office as such when he ceases to processes that religion. 5. Appointment of 1[Deputy and] Assistant Commissioners :– (1) The S tate Government may appoint a 3[Deputy Commissioner] and such number of Assistant Commissioners as they deem necessary. (2) Appointment of the said Officers shall be from among persons who prefers the Hindu religion and who are members of the State Judicial Service. (a) in the case of the 3[Deputy Commissioner,] not below rank of a Subordinate Judge ; and (b) in the case of an Assistant Commissioner, of the rank of a Munsif or above and they shall cease to hold Of fice as such when they cease to profess that religion. 5-A. Officers and Servants to be appointed by the Commissioner :– The Commissioner of Endowment s may, subject to the control of the S tate Government, from time to time, appoint such Sub-ordinate Of ficers and staff, as may be deemed necessary for the purpose of this Act and they shall, subject to the control of the Commissioner, discharge such functions and perform such duties as may be assigned to them by the Commissioner 1[Deputy Commissioner] or the Assistant Commissioners. 6. 4[Conditions of services of Commissioner, Deputy Commissioner, etc.] :– (1) The Commissioner , the Deputy Commissioner , the Assistant Commissioners, the Sub-ordinate Officers and staff appointed under this Act shall be the Servants of the State Government and they shall draw their p ay pension, leave and other allowances from the Consolidated Fund of the State. The conditions of service of such Officers shall be such as may be prescribed from time to time. (2) There shall be p aid out of the Endowment Fund and the S tate Government shall have power to direct the p ayment of, at such time as they may deem fit, such cost as the State Government may from time to time incur from out of the Consolidated Fund on account of pay, pension, leave and other allowances of t he Commissioner , the 3[Deputy Commissioner] Assistant Commissioners, other Sub-ordinate Officers and staff appointed under this Act.] 1. Secs. 4, 5, 5-A and 6 substituted for original Sections 4, 5 and 6 vide O.H.R.E. (Amendment) Act, 1954-O.A. No. 18 of 1954. 2. Substituted vide O.A. No. 29 of 1978. 3. Inserted vide O.A. No. 29 of 1978 - w.e.f. 7.6.1978. 4. Added vide O.A. No. 29 of 1973 - w.e.f. 7.6.1978. 7. Powers and Duties of Commissioner :– (1) Subject to the provisions of this Act, the general superintendence of all Religious institutions and endowments shall vest in the Commissioner. 1[ x x x ] 2[(2)] The Commissioner may do all things which are reasonable and necessary to ensure that the Religious institutions and endowments are properly administered and that their income is duly appropriated for the purposes which they were founded or exist. Explanation :– The Commissioner shall have power to pass such interim orders as he deems necessary for the proper maintenance of a Religious institution, or the proper administration of a Religious endowment including the power to p ass such orders if and when necessary for the proper management of any institution when a dispute concerning the same is pending in a Court. SYNOPSIS 1. Powers of the Commissioner ...... 39 2. Appointment of Interim Trustee .................................................... 39 3. Principles of Natural Justice ....... 40 4. Notice under Order 1 Rule 8 (2) of C.P.C. is mandatory..................... 40 5. Deities being not permanent whether appointment of interim trustees justi- fied .............................................. 40 1. Omitted vide O.H.R.E. (Amendment) Act, 1954-O.A. No. 18 of 1954. 2. Re-numbered ibid. 1. Powers of the Commis- sioner :– As per the provisions of the Sec- tion 35 of the Act if a hereditary trustee is found acting contrary to the provisions of the said section, then he can be declared disqualified after following due proce- dure, making due inquiry as provided under the said section, the Commissioner otherwise cannot suspend the hereditary trustee and constitute the interim trust board as provided U/s- 7 of the Act. (Raj Gopal Ramanuja Das Vs. Commissioner of Endowments, Orissa and others) 2011 (II) OLR 969. 2. Appointment of Interim Trustee :– Scope of the Section – Ex- plained – Validity of appointment of in- terim Trust Board for proper administra- tion of religious institution like Gopinath Jew and Sri Achyutananda Ashram of Nemalo challenged, 2009 (I) CLR 579 (Gangananda Goswamy and others Vs. State of Orissa and Others) Appointment of interim trustees by Commissioner – Duty of the Commis- sioner is to make due inquiry in the mat- ter when there is an objection, as the trust- ees so appointed are interested persons in view of the Section 29 of the Act – Ap- pointment of such trustees is void. Fur - ther distinction between Section 28 and 29 – Explained, 82 (1996) (I) OLR 529 (Anam Charan Mallick and others Vs. Commissioner of Endowment, Bhubaneswar and another) Proceeding U/s- 42 of the Act pending and as per the report of Additional Asssistant Commisioner the personal property of the petitioners which were in question did not belong to religious insti- tution. A Deputy Commissioner Endow- ment appointing the Opp. Parties as an interim trustee under the provision of Sec- tion 7 of the Act without extending due opportunity of hearing to the petitioner which was held to be illegal, 2004 (II) OLR 492, 2004 (II) CLR 513, (Sri Padmanav Giri Goswami Vs. Commis- sioner of Endowment and others) 3. Principles of Natural Jus- tice :– Inspector of Endowment submit- ting a report to form a non-hereditary Trust Board and the same having being sent to the Commissioner – Interim Trust Board can be formed if there is no hereditary trustee – However the Additional Com- missioner or the Commissioner is to make enquiry as to whether there was any he- reditary trustee or not, as the R.O.R. pre- pared in the name of the petitioner . Fur- ther the matter having being in dispute before the Consolidation Authorities, they have interest in the matter. But they have not been given an opportunity of hearing, as such the matter was remanded to the Commissioner to be dispose of after ex- tending due opportunity of hearing to the petitioner. AIR 1999 Orissa 175, 1999 (I) OLR 608 (Jasobanti Thakurani and oth- ers Vs. Commissioner of Endowment and others) 4. Notice under Order 1 Rule 8 (2) of C.P.C. is mandatory :– Assistant Commissioner appointed hereditary trustee which was challenged in appeal. However there being no notice issued un- der Order 1 Rule 8 (2) of C.P.C. The Or- der of the Trial Court is vitiated, 2005 (1) OLR 612, (2005) 1 CLR 702 (Jogiram Mohapatra and other Vs. Sibaram Pradhan and others) 5. Deities being not permanent whether appointment of interim trust- ees justified :– The Commissioner of En- dowment is empowered to appoint interim trustees of the deities who are prepared, worshipped and emer ged every year by the Societies registered under the Society Registration Act. Such action of the au- thorities challenged on the ground that such institution are not Hindu Public Re- ligious Endowment, such question can be decided under the provisions of the Sec- tion 41 of the Act. Thus appointment of interim trustees is not illegal. 2007 (II) OLR 801, 2007 (II) CLR 769 (Haraparbati Thakurani and others Vs. Commissioner of Endowment and others) 8. Powers and Duties of the Deputy and Assistant Commissioners:– 1[(1) 2[The Deputy Commissioner] and the Assistant Commissioners shall exercise such powers and discharge such duties as are assigned to them by or under this Act, either generally or in respect of any particular area : Provided that the Commissioner, may, subject to the other provisions of this Act, by order in writing, declare that the exercise of all or any of such powers and discharge of all or any of such duties shall be subject to such exceptions, limitations and conditions as may be specified in the order and he may himself exercise or discharge any power or duties so expected. 3(2)4[The Deputy Commissioner] and the Assistant Commissioners shall, for the proper management of the institution, have power to pass such interim orders as they deem necessary in the course of proceedings pending before them.] 1. Re-numbered vide O.A. No. 29 of 1978. 2. Inserted ibid. 3. Added ibid. 4. Inserted ibid. SYNOPSIS 1. Application of the Provisions ..... 41 2. Upmost care is required for Appointment of Trustee .............. 41 3. Principles of Natural Justice ....... 42 4. Summary Inquiry before appointing non hereditary trustee ................. 41 5. Institution is to be a religious one .................................................... 42 1. Application of the Provisions:– Distinction between Sections 27 and 41 explains the question whether the religious institution is managed or not managed by the hereditary trustee is to be decided un- der Section 41, 69 (1990) CL T 213 (Baikunthanath Patjoshi and others Vs. Commissioner of Endowment of Orissa, Bhubaneswar and others) The provisions of the section vested powers on the Commissioner of Endowment to transfer any appeal to the Deputy Commissioner for disposal, 72 (1991) CLT 277 (Raghunath Das after him Kamini Dei @ Krishna Kamini Dei and others Vs. Sri Grama Devati Ambica Thakurani and others) 2. Upmost car e is r equired for Appointment of Trustee :– Appointment of non hereditary trustee is to be made with utmost expedition in order to avoid mismanagement and misappropriation. While doing so the Assistant Commis- sioner is to make a summary inquiry which must be reasonable and satisfac- tory holding that whether there is a he- reditary trustee in the institution or not. If the order is arbitrary than the said order can be challenged in the revision. 81 (1996) CLT 477 (Dhadi Parida after him Sundari Parida and others Vs. Commis- sioner of Consolidation and others) Before exercising the powers un- der Section 8B of the Act, the Commis- sioner is required to form an opinion on the basis of the objective material. It can- not be his ipse dixit without any support- ing materials, whatsoever . Such power cannot be used arbitrarily. Thus whether a disputed matha is a public religious insti- tution is to be decided and adjudicated U/ s- 41 (1) (a) (d) of the Act, 94 (2002) CLT 30 (Jayaram Dash Jee Maharaj and after him Mahanta Premananda Dash Jee Vs. Commissioner of Endowment, Orissa and another) The Assistant Commissioner of Endowment can exercise its jurisdiction for appointment of non-hereditary trust- ees whether any proceeding under the pro- visions of Section 41 of the Act is pend- ing or not, 2006 (I) CLR 230 (Sri Chandi Thakurani Bije at Bakharabad, Jagatsinghpur Vs. State of Orissa and oth- ers) Whether order passed U/s-7 can be treated to have been passed U/s-8B of the Act because of the non-obstante clause contained. As per the provisions of Sec- tion 8-B, a summary enquiry is to be con- ducted with regard to the fact that the in- stitution is a religious one, 2004 (II) OLR 492, 2004 (II) CLR 513, (Sri Padmanav Giri Goswami Vs. Commissioner of En- dowment and others) 3. Principles of Natural Jus- tice :– It is an established principle of law that any person having interest in the dis- puted lands before passing an order is to be given an opportunity of hearing, 88 (1999) CLT 549 (Harihara Chatuari and others Vs. Commissioner of Endowment, Orissa and others) 4. Summary Inquiry before ap- pointing non hereditary trustee :– The Assistant Commissioner while appointing a non- hereditary trustee is to conduct a summary inquiry into the matter and he is to satisfied with regard to the necessity and also it is to be seen whether there is any hereditary trustee or not. However , the Commissioner is not debarred from ex- ercising the powers as provided U/s- 27 in case of any application pending U/s- 41 of the Act. In view of the amendment of 1973, thus any order passed by the As- sistant Commissioner is revisable, 1999 (1) OLR 163 (Sri Sri Raghunath Jew and another Vs. Commissioner of Endowment Orissa and others) 5. Institution is to be a religious one :– The Authorities are to be satisfied before taking any action under the provi- sions of the section prima facie that the institution is a religious one. 2004 (II) OLR 492, 99 (2005) CL T 1 17 ((Sri) Padmanav Giri Goswami Vs. Commis- sioner of Endowment and Others) 1[8-A. Delegation of Power by the Commissioner :– The Commissioner may transfer any appeal filed before him to 1[the Deputy Commissioner] for hearing and disposal and any appeal so transferred and disposed of by 4[the Deputy Commissioner] shall, for the purposes of this Act, be deemed to have been disposed of by the Commissioner. 8-B. Power of authorities to act without initiating proceedings under Section 41 :– (1) Notwithstanding anything contained in any other provision of this Act the Commissioner , 1[the Deputy Commissioner] and the Assistant Commissioners shall have power to take action under any of the provisions of this Act in respect of any institution, if on information received or otherwise, they are satisfied that such institution is a Religious institution within the meaning of this Act. (2) For the removal of doubts, it is hereby declared that where any person disputes such action on the ground that the institution is not a Religious institution within the meaning of this Act, he may raise a dispute as provided in Section 41.] 9. Power of Commissioner to call for Records and Pass Orders :– (1) The Commissioner may call for and examine 2[the record of any proceeding under this Act before the Deputy Commissioner 3[or before an Assistant Commissioner except under Sub-Section (1) of Section 27] to satisfy himself as to the regularity of such proceeding or the correctness, legality or propriety of any decision or order p assed thereon; and if in any case it appears to the Commissioner that any such decision or order shall be modified, annulled, reversed or remitted for reconsideration, he may pass orders accordingly: Provided that the Commissioner shall not pass any order prejudicial to any party without hearing him or giving him a reasonable opportunity of being heard : 1. Inserted ibid. 2. Substituted vide O.A. No. 29 of 1978. 3. Sustituted vide O.A. No. 13 of 2003 (O.G.E. No. 825 dated 31.5.2003). 1[Provided further that in cases where an appeal lies under this Act, no proceedings by way of revision shall be entert ained by the Commissioner at the instance of a person who could have appealed: Provided also that nothing in this Sub-Section shall apply to the proceedings in an appeal transferred by the Commissioner to the Deputy Commissioner for hearing and disposal. (2) The Commissioner may stay the execution of any such decision or order, pending the exercise of his power under Sub-Section (1) in respect thereof. Notes :– Revisional Power of the Commissioner not abridged or taken away 76 (1993) CLT 434 (Gouranga Jena Vs. Commissioner of Endowments and others) 10. 2[ x x x ] 11. 3[ x x x ] 12. Power to enter Religious Institutions :– (1) The Commissioner, 1[the Deputy Commissioner] and Assistant Commissioners and such other Officers professing Hindu religion as may be authorised by the Commissioner in this behalf shall have power to enter 4[subject to the local practice, customs or usages] 2[the premises of any Religious institution or] any place of worship at any reasonable hour for the purpose of exercising any power conferred, or discharging any duty imposed, by or under this Act. 2[ x x x ] (2) If any such Of ficer is resisted in the exercise of such power or discharge of such duty , the Magistrate having jurisdiction shall, on a written requisition from such Officer, direct any Police Officer not being below the rank of Sub-Inspector to render such help as may be necessary to enable the Officer to exercise such power or discharge such duty. (3) Nothing in this Section shall be deemed to authorise any person who is not a Hindu to enter the premises or place referred to in Sub-Section (1) or any part thereof. 13. Trustee bound to obey orders issued under the act :– The Trustee of a Religious institution shall be bound to obey all orders issued under the provisions of this Act by the State Government, the Commissioner, 1[the Deputy Commissioner] or 5[an] Assistant Commissioner. Notes :– Acts and omissions of the authorities not ground to prove the claim :– Onus lies on the plaintiff to prove that the mahant a who sold the properties to him was the absolute owner of the property – Inference cannot be drawn from the act or omission of the authorities under the Endowment Act and 1. Inserted vide O.A. No. 29 of 1978. 2. Omitted ibid. 3. Inserted ibid. 4. Inserted vide O.A. No. 18 of 1954. 5. Substituted vide O.A. No. 18 of 1954. Collector to confer title of the property on the mahant a as a owner of the properties, 2004 (I) CLR 71, (Madhu Sudan Panda and af ter him Mukta Devi and others Vs. The Commissioner of Endowment, Orissa and others) 14. Care required of T rustee and his Powers :– (1) The Trustee of every Religious Institution is bound to administer it s affairs and to apply it s funds and properties in accordance with the terms of the trust, the usage of the institution and all lawful directions which a competent authority may issue in respect thereof and as carefully as a man of ordinary prudence would deal with such affairs, funds and properties as if they were his own. (2) A Trustee shall, subject to the provisions of this Act, be entitled to exercise all powers incidental to the provident and beneficial administration of the Religious institution and to do all things necessary for the due performance of the duties imposed on him. (3) A Trustee shall not be entitled to spend the funds of the Religious Institution for meeting any costs, charges or expenses incurred by him in any suit, appeal or application or other proceeding for, or incidental to, his removal from Office or the taking or any disciplinary action against him . Provided that the Trustee may reimburse himself in respect of such costs, charges or expenses if he is specifically permitted to do so by an order passed under Section 69. 15. Preparation of Register for all Institutions :– (1) For every Religious institution, there shall be prepared and maintained a register showing– (a) the names of past and present Trustees and particulars as to the custom, or the direction of the founder, if any, regarding succession to the Office of Trustee; (b) particulars of all endowments of the institution and all title deeds and other documents including the properties standing in the name of the hereditary Trustees relating thereto ; (c) particulars of the scheme of administration and of the scale of expenditure. (d) the names of all Of ficers to which any salary , emolument or perquisite is attached and the nature, time and conditions of service in each case ; (e) the jewels, gold, silver , precious stones, all vessels and other movables belonging to the institution with their estimated value ; (f) particulars of the idols and other images in or connected with the institution, whether intended for worship or for being carried in processions; (g) such other particulars as may be required by 1[the Commissioners]. 1. Substituted vide Odisha Act No. 18 of 1954. (2) The register shall be prepared, signed and verified by the Trustee of the institutions concerned or by his authorised agent and submitted by him to 1[the Commissioner], in duplicate through the Assistant Commissioner, within one year from the commencement of this Act or from the founding of the institution, as the case may be, or within such further period not exceeding one year as may be allowed by 1[the Commissioner]: Provided that each Trustee shall be required to swear an af fidavit that the list of properties, both movable or immovable, owned by the institution and furnished, is exhaustive : Provided further that this Sub-Section shall not apply where a register so signed and verified has been submitted to 1[the Commissioner] before the commencement of this Act. (3) The Assistant Commissioner may , after such enquiry as he may consider necessary, recommend such alterations, omissions or additions in the register as he may think fit. (4) 1[The Commissioner] may , af ter receiving the register and the recommendations of the Assistant Commissioner with respect thereto and making such further inquiry, as he may consider necessary, direct the Trustee to make such alterations, omissions or additions in the register as he may deem fit. (5) The Trustee shall carry out the orders of 1[the Commissioner] and then submit the register to 1[the Commissioner] for approval. (6) A Copy of the register as approved by 1[the Commissioner] shall be furnished to the Trustee and to the Assistant Commissioner concerned. 16. Annual Verification of the Register :– (1) The Trustee or his authorised agent shall scrutinise the entries in the register every year, or after such interval, as may be prescribed and submit to the Commissioner for his approval, through the Assistant Commissioner, a verified statement showing the alterations, omissions or additions required in the register. (2) The Commissioner may, thereupon, af ter such inquiry as he may consider necessary, direct what alternations, omissions or additions, if any , should be made in the register. (3) A Copy of the order made under Sub-Section (2) shall be furnished to the Trustee and to the Assistant Commissioner concerned. (4) The Trustee shall carry out the alterations, omissions or additions ordered by the Commissioner in the Copy of the register kept by him. 17. Trustee to furnish accounts, returns, etc. :– The Trustee of every Religious institution shall furnish to the Commissioner , 2[the Deputy Commissioner] or the Assistant Commissioner such accounts, returns, reports or other informations relating to the administration of the institution in his charge, 1. Substituted vide Odisha Act No. 18 of 1954. 2. Inserted vide O.A. No. 29 of 1978. its funds, property or income or moneys connected therewith, or the appropriation thereof, as the Commissioner , 1[the Deputy Commissioner] or the Assistant Commissioner may require, and at such time and in such form as he may direct. 18. Inspection of Property and Documents :– The Commissioner, 1[the Deputy Commissioner] or Assistant Commissioner, or any Officer or other person deputed by the Commissioner , 1[the Deputy Commissioner] or Assistant Commissioner in this behalf, may inspect all movable and immovable property belonging to all records, correspondence, plans, accounts and other documents relating to any Religious, institution; and it shall be the duty of the Trustee of such institution and all Officers and Servants working under him, his agent and any person having concern in the administration thereof, to af ford all such assistance and facilities as may be necessary or reasonably required in regard to such inspection, and also produce any such movable property or document for inspection if so required. 2[19. Alienation of immovable trust Property :– (1) Notwithstanding anything contained in any law for the time being in force no transfer be exchange, sale or mortgage and no lease for a team exceeding five years of any immovable property belonging to , or given or endowed for the purpose of, any Religious institution, shall be made unless it is sanctioned and no such transfer shall be valid or operative unless it is so sanctioned. 3[Explanation :– A lease for a term not exceeding five years but with a condition of renewal permitting continuance of the lease beyond five years shall, for the purpose of this Sub-Section, be deemed to be a lease for a term exceeding five years. (1-a) The fact of execution of a lease deed with a condition for renewal or renewal of such a deed shall be communicated to the Commissioner by the Trustee not later than fifteen days from the date of execution. (1-b) After expiry of the term of the lease the lessee shall deliver possession of the leasehold land to the lessor, failing which, the Commissioner may take action in accordance with the provision of Section 68: Provided that all structures, permanent or temporary, if any, constructed plants and machineries and other things inst alled and kept on the leasehold land, which is a subject-matter of a lease executed after commencement of the Odisha Hindu Religious Endowments (Amendment) Act 22 of 1989 by the lessee, his Servants or agents, shall become the property of the Religious institution unless removed from the land within such period, as may be prescribed, after expiry of the term of lease, in respect of which the Commissioner shall t ake action under the provision of Section 68. 1. Inserted vide O.A. No. 29 of 1978. 2. Substituted vide O.H.R.E. (Amendment) Act, 1954-O.A. No. 18 of 1954. 3. Inserted vide O.A. No. 22 of 1989. (1-c) Notwithstanding anything contained in the proviso to Sub-Section (1-b), no property belonging to a person other than the lessee shall be subjected to confiscation under the said proviso, unless such person fails to remove his property within a period of thirty days from the date of publication of a notice which shall be issued by the Trustee within such period as may be prescribed after the expiry of the term of lease : Provided that any person whose property is affected under Sub-Section (1-c), may file an application to the Commissioner claiming the property whose decision shall, subject to the decision of the Civil Court, be final.] (2) In according such sanction, the Comm
Excerpt shown. Open the full act in Lexace.
Lex